
I saw Barbie movie, it was entertaining. I like the dance number, set production, and the outfit because it did look like the toys from Mattel but it is not as innocent as it looks.
Thanks to Barbie, I now know that the patriarchy, which subjugated women and made it challenging for them to be a woman (based on America’s speech), can be challenged by engaging men’s ego; by exploiting their egoistic and childish tendencies, making them jealous, and pitting them against one another. What a mature way to undo patriarchy, which by the way was mentioned in the movie till kingdom come.
And that in life, to have identity you need autonomy (self-government) because having a partner can influence one’s identity, which make one inauthentic based on their narrative. This is why Barbie doesn’t need Ken and Ken doesn’t need Barbie so each can create their own, true, and free-from-influence personhood.
However, all the success gained by the Barbies from going through the trouble of fighting the patriarchy and asserting autonomy to find oneself suddenly went to naught as the idea of “being ordinary is ok” was promoted in the end. This part confused me, what’s the message, equality and autonomy or being ordinary? Are there 2 or 3 messages?
There’s no problem with being ordinary because it is in the ordinary that we find meaning to life. We can even find our identity in the simple tasks we do daily. This brings me to ask the question: will Mattel spend its resources to make ordinary Barbies, bring back pregnant Barbies, sales lady Barbies, Brick layer Barbies, fat Barbies, cleaner Barbie, dishwasher Barbies, so they can be true and authentic to its message?
Additionally, the portrayal of the patriarchy (male dominated society) is totally one sided and only creates division between men and women. The movie failed to show the significant roles and contributions of women in society since time immemorial, including top positions in government and corporations, and the nurturing roles of mothers in the formation of great leaders who have contributed to society.
Furthermore, the suggestion of the need for Nietzschean autonomy is problematic. While autonomy is valued, it is crucial to note that autonomy cannot be absolute as no man can be entirely himself because man will always be a part of something.
Absolute autonomy, the assertion of one’s will and power, only leads to division and radical individualism and undermines the value of relationships that lead to the creation of families.
Injecting ideas that (young) women are disadvantaged because they live in a patriarchal society and autonomy is the answer to finding one’s identity harms not just the person but also the society as a whole. Society is not built by one person, one gender, or one race, but by a combination of strength and care from diverse people.
The movie appears to be harmless because it’s visually appealing but when you unpack the message, it’s full of harmful ideas. The movie is akin to a candy that looks sweet but turns sour when eaten. But do watch it and see for yourself.


